Skip to content
In-stock items ship within 2 business days | Free ground shipping within the USA
In-stock: ships in 2 days | Free US ground shipping
matace beige and yellow carpet squares are laid out in the ins style restaurant.

Carpet Squares VS Traditional Carpet: Which is More Cost-Effective?

When it comes to revamping your living space, the choice of flooring can be a pivotal decision. One common dilemma that homeowners often face is whether to opt for traditional wall-to-wall carpeting or embrace the modern trend of carpet squares. While aesthetics and comfort play a significant role in this choice, the element of cost-effectiveness cannot be ignored. In this blog, we'll delve into the world of carpeting and explore the question, "Are carpet squares cheaper than carpet?" We'll analyze the key factors, advantages, and styles associated with carpet squares and traditional carpeting to help you make an informed decision for your home improvement project.

Matace beige and yellow carpet squares are laid side by side in the ins style restaurant.

Understanding Carpet Squares

Defining Carpet Squares

Carpet squares, often referred to as carpet tiles or modular carpet, are a popular flooring option that offers versatility and ease of installation. These square-shaped pieces of carpet come in various sizes, typically ranging from 18 inches by 18 inches to 24 inches by 24 inches. Each carpet square is designed to fit seamlessly with the others, allowing for a customized and unique flooring layout.

Advantages of Carpet Squares

Carpet squares come with several advantages that make them an attractive choice for homeowners. One of their standout features is the ease of installation. Unlike traditional carpet rolls, carpet squares can be laid down individually, making them a DIY-friendly option. Additionally, if a section becomes stained or damaged, you can replace individual squares instead of the entire carpet.

Variety in Styles and Designs

Carpet squares offer an extensive range of styles and designs to cater to diverse tastes and interior decor themes. Whether you prefer a classic, timeless look or a modern, vibrant aesthetic, you can find carpet squares that align with your vision. From solid colors to intricate patterns, the variety of choices in carpet squares is impressive.

Traditional Carpet: The Conventional Choice

Introduction to Traditional Carpet

Traditional carpet, the time-tested flooring option, has been adorning homes for generations. It's characterized by its seamless rolls of carpeting, providing a classic and cozy ambiance to any space. Let's delve into what makes traditional carpet an enduring choice.

Installation Process and Challenges

Installing traditional carpet involves specific steps, typically requiring professional assistance. The process entails measuring, cutting, and securing the carpet rolls to the floor. However, there can be challenges, such as ensuring the carpet lies flat without wrinkles and achieving a consistent appearance throughout the room. Proper installation is critical to the longevity and aesthetics of traditional carpet.

A World of Choices: Textures, Colors, and Materials

One of the standout features of traditional carpet is the vast array of options it offers. Homeowners can choose from various textures, including plush, berber, and frieze, each providing a distinct look and feel. The color palette is virtually limitless, allowing you to match or contrast with your interior decor. Moreover, traditional carpet comes in different materials, such as nylon, polyester, wool, or blends, each with its unique properties in terms of durability and comfort.

 Cost Comparison

Analyzing Upfront Costs of Carpet Squares

To address the question, "Are carpet squares cheaper than carpet?" it's essential to break down the costs. Carpet squares are typically sold per square foot, and their prices can vary depending on factors like quality and design. We will delve into these costs and consider any additional expenses like adhesives or underlayments, which may be required for installation. 

Of course there are carpet squares on the market that don't require glue and contain pads in the structure of the itself. For example: Matace!

Costs Associated with Traditional Carpet

Traditional carpet involves not only the cost of the carpet itself but also labor expenses for professional installation. We'll explore the price range of traditional carpeting materials and the installation fees that can vary based on the complexity of the project. This comprehensive view will help us understand the complete financial picture.

Side-by-Side Cost Comparison

To provide clarity and make an informed decision, we'll present a side-by-side cost comparison. We'll use a hypothetical room size as a reference point, breaking down the expenses for both carpet squares and traditional carpeting. By comparing these costs, you'll be better equipped to assess the financial aspect of your flooring choice and determine which option aligns with your budget and preferences.

 Long-Term Durability and Maintenance

Durability of Carpet Squares

When considering the long-term viability of carpet squares, durability is a key factor to assess. Carpet squares are known for their resilience, as they are designed to withstand heavy foot traffic and resist wear and tear. Their construction, often with high-quality materials, contributes to their ability to maintain their appearance over time. Additionally, the modular nature of carpet squares allows for easy replacement of damaged sections, extending their overall lifespan.

Maintenance Requirements

Both carpet squares and traditional carpeting require maintenance to keep them looking their best. Regular vacuuming is essential for removing dirt and debris from the surface. However, carpet squares have an advantage in terms of maintenance due to their modularity. If a portion of the carpet squares becomes stained or damaged beyond repair, you can simply replace those specific squares instead of replacing the entire floor.

Traditional carpeting, on the other hand, may necessitate more extensive cleaning methods, such as steam cleaning or professional deep cleaning services, depending on the type of material and the severity of stains.

Calculating Long-Term Maintenance Costs

To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of carpet squares versus traditional carpet over the long term, it's crucial to calculate potential maintenance expenses. Consider factors such as the frequency of cleaning, the cost of cleaning products or services, and the likelihood of repairs or replacements. By comparing these costs, you can get a clearer picture of the financial implications of each flooring option throughout its lifespan.

 Environmental Impact

Sustainability in Carpeting Choices

When considering whether to install carpet squares or traditional carpet, it's essential to take into account the environmental impact of your decision. Let's explore the various facets of sustainability in carpeting choices.

 Manufacturing Processes and Materials

Carpet Squares: Carpet squares often have an edge in terms of sustainability due to their efficient manufacturing processes. They are typically made from recycled or recyclable materials, reducing the demand for new resources. Additionally, the production of carpet squares can generate less waste compared to traditional carpet rolls.

Traditional Carpet: Traditional carpet manufacturing processes can vary widely in terms of environmental impact. Some traditional carpets are made from synthetic materials that may not be eco-friendly, while others use natural fibers like wool, which are more sustainable. It's crucial to consider the materials used in traditional carpet when assessing its environmental footprint.

Lifecycle Impact

Consider the lifecycle impact of your carpeting choice. While both carpet squares and traditional carpet can be environmentally responsible at the manufacturing stage, their long-term sustainability may differ.

Carpet Squares: The modularity of carpet squares allows for easy replacement of damaged or stained tiles, extending the life of the flooring. This reduces the need for frequent replacements, ultimately reducing waste and resource consumption.

Traditional Carpet: Traditional carpet may require more extensive maintenance and replacement if damaged, potentially contributing to more waste over its lifespan. However, the sustainability of traditional carpet can be improved by choosing durable materials and proper maintenance.

 Personal Preferences and Aesthetics

The Influence of Personal Style

When it comes to designing your living space, your personal style and preferences should take center stage. Your choice of flooring, whether it's carpet squares or traditional carpet, should align with your unique vision for your home. 

Tips for Choosing the Right Carpeting

  1. Consider the Atmosphere: Think about the ambiance you want to create in each room. Carpet squares can bring a modern and modular feel, while traditional carpet exudes warmth and timelessness. Choose accordingly to set the desired tone.

  2. Color Harmony: Pay attention to color coordination. Carpet squares offer diverse color options, allowing you to experiment with bold or subtle hues. Traditional carpet, on the other hand, offers classic and neutral tones. Ensure your choice complements your existing decor.

  3. Texture and Comfort: Your tactile preferences matter. If you value softness and plushness underfoot, traditional carpet may be more appealing. Carpet squares offer a variety of textures, from sleek to textured, catering to different sensory experiences.

  4. Pattern Play: Decide if you prefer patterned or solid flooring. Carpet squares can be arranged to create intricate patterns or kept uniform, offering flexibility in design. Traditional carpet may limit pattern choices but can still provide elegance through its texture.

  5. Maintenance Considerations: Think about your lifestyle and maintenance capabilities. Carpet squares allow for easy replacement of individual tiles, making them suitable for high-traffic areas. Traditional carpet may require more intensive cleaning but can offer a cozy retreat in bedrooms and living spaces.

Matace beige and olive green carpet squares are laid side by side in the ins style living room.

Introducing Matace Carpet Squares: The Ultimate Flooring Solution

When it comes to revamping your home's flooring, Matace Carpet Squares stand out as an exceptional choice that combines convenience, durability, and style. These 19.69" x 19.69" carpet squares have been designed with several unique features that make them a top pick for anyone considering a flooring upgrade.

1. Easy to Install and Replace

One of the standout features of Matace Carpet Squares is their hassle-free installation process. These squares boast a self-suction design, eliminating the need for adhesives or tape. Whether you're a DIY enthusiast or a first-time installer, you'll find that laying down these carpet squares is a breeze. What's even more impressive is their ease of replacement. Should you need to clean or replace an individual tile, simply pick it up without disturbing the rest of your flooring – a true testament to their user-friendly design.

2. Stain and Fade Resistant

Matace Carpet Squares are crafted from multi-level loop Polypropylene fiber, ensuring exceptional durability and resistance to stains, bleach, and fading. This feature is particularly important for high-traffic areas and homes with active families or pets. You can rest easy knowing that your flooring will maintain its vibrant appearance even in the face of everyday wear and tear.

3. Seamless Appearance

The proprietary technology used in crafting Matace Carpet Squares allows for a seamless appearance that adds a touch of sophistication to your living space. While the subtle seams between the carpet tiles create a continuous look, the individual tiles can be effortlessly removed for cleaning or replacement whenever needed. This balance of aesthetics and practicality is a key advantage for those who value both form and function.

4. Comfortable and Safe

With a thickness of .33 inches and an anti-slip backing, Matace Carpet Squares provide not only a comfortable underfoot experience but also enhanced safety. The effective cushioning they offer is not only kind to your feet but also helps prevent knee joint injuries that can result from slipping and falling. These carpet squares are designed to prioritize your well-being.

5. Machine Washable

Maintaining your flooring has never been easier. Matace Carpet Squares are machine washable and dryable, simplifying the cleaning process. To ensure the longevity of your squares, it's recommended to use a laundry bag during the wash cycle, preventing any unintentional wear and tear.


In conclusion, Matace Carpet Squares present an excellent flooring solution for those seeking a combination of convenience, style, and durability. Their easy installation and replacement, stain and fade resistance, seamless appearance, comfort, and machine washability make them a standout choice for any home. Whether you're looking to refresh a single room or transform your entire living space, Matace Carpet Squares are a versatile and practical option to consider.

Previous article The Ultimate Guide to Espresso Coffee Mats: Find Your Perfect Match

Leave a comment

Comments must be approved before appearing

* Required fields